I avoid using the word “actress.” I long ago stopped using “fireman” and “spokesman,” and I never used bygone terms like “aviatrix” or “authoress.” I don’t say “male nurse” or “female Marine.”
So I typically use “actor” to describe a person who acts (it does complicate things that “actor” was masculine in the original Latin, but that, for me, is akin to how my last name is made up of my father’s and my husband’s, respectively, so let’s just get on with it). If your job is to act, 90 percent of the time I’m going to call you an actor.
And then there’s the Oscars, the nominations for which will be announced Tuesday. Any other day I’d call Laurie Metcalf an actor; if she gets a nomination for “Lady Bird,” I’ll have to refer to her as “a nominee for best actress.” The categories for the acting awards are clear – but why?
The Pulitzers aren’t divided by sex; neither are the MacArthur “genius grants.” Competitive Scrabble isn’t; neither is professional poker. Because no matter what you think about the difference between female and male brains, when it comes to these artistic and intellectual pursuits, the individual skills are the same for men and women. So why do the Oscars treat acting differently? (In the spirit of #notallawards, last year Emma Watson won the MTV Movie & TV Award for best actor, a gender-neutral award.)
None of the other Academy Awards categories are divided by gender: There’s no best female director, no best male costume designer. Why not open the best acting and the best supporting acting categories to 10 nominees each and let the pink and blue chips fall where they may? If the skills and abilities are the same, then let the top actors, male and female, battle it out on a level playing field.
The only problem is that “level playing field” thing.
I highly doubt that a gender-neutral competition would fall into a 50-50 split. My gut tells me more men than women would get nominated, not because of any overt sexism, but because men are more likely to get the meaty roles that the Academy likes to recognize.
Take last year: If lead performances were all lumped together, there is no WAY Meryl Streep would have been nominated for “Florence Foster Jenkins,” because Joel Edgerton, who was snubbed for his role in “Loving,” would have edged her out. Not because Streep’s performance wasn’t great – she could get a nomination for breathing in and out – but because his role was much more Oscar-y. He got the silent, tortured, emotional role; she got handicapped by comedy, which made her a dark horse even in the all-female category. The skills and abilities of top actors might be the same, but the opportunities are not.
While there are niche awards ceremonies that serve to draw at least some attention to often-marginalized or underrepresented groups, the Oscars are where the spotlight shines brightest – not just on the stars, but on the Hollywood system itself. The gender imbalance in the roles that are available shapes what’s awarded. Until women are afforded the same number of high-quality roles that men are, the categories have to be separate to even have a shot at making the recognition equal.
—
WINNERS IN MY BOOK
Not everyone who deserves an acting nod gets one. Here are 10 performances that might not nab Oscars but are still among the best of 2017:
– Everyone, basically, “Mudbound”
– Betty Gabriel, “Get Out”
– Tiffany Haddish, “Girls Trip”
– Tom Holland, “Spider-Man: Homecoming”
– Hugh Jackman, “Logan”
– Daniel Kaluuya, “Get Out”
– Ezra Miller, “Justice League”
– Andy Serkis, “War for the Planet of the Apes”
– Keala Settle, “The Greatest Showman”
– Daniela Vega, “A Fantastic Woman.”
RELATED STORIES:
It’s time Hollywood’s male stars use their power to level playing field
After outcry, Mark Wahlberg donates $1.5M film fee to Time’s Up in Michelle Williams’ name
Women directed some of 2017’s best films, but new data shows they’re still underrepresented
.galleries:after {
content: ”;
display: block;
background-color: #144A7C;
margin: 16px auto 0;
height: 5px;
width: 100px;
}
.galleries:before {
content: “Entertainment Photos and Video”;
display: block;
font: 700 20px Georgia,serif;
text-align: center;
color: #1e1e1e;
var playlist = ‘chi_ent_movie_trailers’,
layout = ‘autoblurb’,
iu = ‘%2F4011%2Ftrb.chicagotribune%2Fent’;
Watch the latest movie trailers.