"America's Next Top Model": We miss Janice Dickinson, of course, but Paulina has proven just as sharp with just enough bitch to put her above Twiggy. Nigel's British accent always lends him extra credibility in our eyes and the fabulous Miss J provides us with his wondrous ensembles and catty comebacks. And, of course, there's Tyra and her smiling eyes.
"Make Me a Supermodel": Model Jenny Shimizu, designer Catherine Malandrino, model scout Marlon and photographer Perou all sit in judgment from those tiny little desks that we sat in during grade school.
Which one is fiercer? "Top Model" - "Supermodel's" judging panel had to be replaced en masse from last season and the new guys are still a snoozefest.