"Airline loyalty programs fail to engage." Deloitte says that a "remarkable" 72 percent of high-frequency business travelers belong to more than one airline program. Zounds! Earlier, when I was a high-frequency business traveler, I belonged to four: American, PanAm, TWA and United. Yes, I used United when I could, but often flew others for better schedules or fares. Now, I still belong to the programs of all three network lines that serve my home airport in Medford, Ore. -- Alaska, Delta and United -- as well as a few others I joined for access to some information.
Overall, Deloitte seems to have overcomplicated a straightforward situation. Basic consumer guidelines remain pretty simple:
-- If you travel a lot, you already know that the most important loyalty-program objective is elite status, not miles. The holy grail of elite status is getting high enough to score no-cost upgrades a fair share of the time. And you also enjoy a bunch of other benefits on baggage check, seat assignments and such. Nothing else comes close. That means trying very hard to fly at least 25,000 miles a year, and preferably more, on your primary airline. Interestingly, I couldn't find a single reference to "complimentary upgrades" in the Deloitte study's list of preference factors.
-- The miles element of frequent flyer programs is as much a cash cow for the airlines as it is a loyalty lure. Airlines rake in billions of dollars a year by selling miles to third parties -- mainly banks that issue credit cards -- and they can make it very tough when you try to use those miles to score a "free" seat.
-- Even infrequent flyers should concentrate flying and miles with one airline, as much as possible: A few thousand miles in each of several programs are essentially worthless. But belonging to multiple programs doesn't have anything to do with remaining loyal to any one line; membership doesn't cost anything, members receive useful information and a little bit of an occasional bump in treatment even if they fly a given line only occasionally. Moreover, credit is worth only about 1 cent a mile, so paying more than a few dollars extra to fly a preferred airline seldom makes sense when some other line has a lower fare or better schedule.
-- If you earn most of your credit through a credit card, you're better off with a card that gives a generous cash or cash-equivalent payout, such as Capital One's Venture cards, that give you up to two cents per dollar charged in travel benefits.
-- Airline miles are more valuable than cash back only when you use them for upgrades or premium class seats.
Although the airline business would make anyone cynical, I try not to become totally jaundiced. But it's difficult not to conclude that the main objective of the Deloitte study is to generate business for Deloitte's loyalty program consultants. As the overview points out, "We are available to assist clients in implementing these strategies." No kidding.
(Send e-mail to Ed Perkins at firstname.lastname@example.org. Perkins' new book for small business and independent professionals, "Business Travel When It's Your Money," is now available through http://www.mybusinesstravel.com or http://www.amazon.com)