'American Sniper' criticism makes for amusing theater

"American Sniper"

Sienna Miller, Clint Eastwood, center, and Bradley Cooper arrive at the "American Sniper" New York Premiere on Dec. 15, 2014. (Theo Wargo, Getty Images / December 15, 2014)

I've got to admit that it has been a barrel of fun watching the political left get its "Je suis Charlie" all tied up in knots over the movie "American Sniper."

They're tweeting and making angry faces, insisting that the movie is not appropriate history. And generally their antics have been quite amusing.

I'm trying to imagine them as they might have been eons ago, in prehistoric times. Hairier perhaps, shorter of bone, shouting aggressively at the shadow puppets flickering on the wall of the main cave after a feast because they didn't much like the story.

"American Sniper" is directed by Clint Eastwood and stars Oscar-nominated Bradley Cooper as Navy SEAL sniper Chris Kyle, who is said to have been the deadliest sniper in American military history.

It is a huge box office success, pulling in over $107 million in its first four days. I saw it just the other day and I liked it, but perhaps not for the reasons you might think.

Not only do conservatives like the movie, but people who aren't all that overtly political are paying good money to see it too. You might know the type.

President Barack Obama once dismissed them (rather tolerantly, he must have thought) by saying they're really simple folk who can't help but "cling to their guns and their religion."

And they're the ones the U.S. calls upon when it's time to kill the bad guys.

Yet as Americans flock to this movie, we should realize that some see it as a sign of aggression. Liberal American Internet organs pulsate with criticism, but it was the Guardian — a British paper of leftist politics yet unassailable soccer coverage — that led the pack.

"The real American Sniper was a hate-filled killer," railed the Guardian. "Why are simplistic patriots treating him as a hero?"


Because he killed the enemy and he didn't whine about it.

"My uncle killed by sniper in WW2," tweeted Michael Moore, the liberal filmmaker. "We were taught snipers were cowards. Will shoot u in the back. Snipers aren't heroes. And invaders r worse."

Moore wasn't alone. Comedian Seth Rogen also ripped the film initially. They then backtracked their comments, and the backpedaling only added to the theater.

Others jumped in, insisting that Kyle wasn't a hero, arguing that he was a racist, or at least an unwitting totem of American jingoism.

Naturally, Republicans started calling the left a bunch of wusses, and Sarah Palin started swinging, rhetorically, and now they're all happily slugging the figurative guts out of each other in name of freedom of expression.

I don't want to spoil the film so I'll tread carefully here, but was Cooper's work Oscar worthy?


But does the movie glorify Kyle as a hero?


  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Connect with us

60° | 60°
68° | 50°
Partly cloudy
78° | 54°

Events Calendar

Browse Print Ads

Browse Print Ads
News Coverage on Paul Brown - CTNow
RSS feeds allow Web site content to be gathered via feed reader software. Click the subscribe link to obtain the feed URL for this page. The feed will update when new content appears on this page.

Paul Brown

A collection of news and information related to Paul Brown published by this site and its partners.

Top Paul Brown Articles see all

Displaying items 1-5
  • Tyrod Taylor makes most of extended playing time

    Tyrod Taylor makes most of extended playing time
    CINCINNATI — Tyrod Taylor prides himself on being an escape artist, dodging defenders with his nimble feet and fast reactions.
  • Ravens coach John Harbaugh will be honored with statue at alma mater

    Ravens coach John Harbaugh will be honored with statue at alma mater
    Ravens coach John Harbaugh will be inducted into the Cradle of Coaches Association and immortalized with a statue at Miami University's Yager Stadium, the school's Director of Athletics David Sayler announced today. Harbaugh, who led the Ravens to their...

    The life of former Ravens owner Art Modell [Timeline]

    The life of former Ravens owner Art Modell [Timeline]
    March 21, 1961: Modell bought the Browns for just under $4 million. Aug. 18, 1962: Modell proposed and staged pro football's first preseason doubleheader at Cleveland Stadium. The Browns played the Steelers in one game and the Lions faced the Cowboys...

    Legacy of Art Modell will be NFL on TV, moving Browns from Cleveland

    Legacy of Art Modell will be NFL on TV, moving Browns from Cleveland
    Art Modell forever will be known as the man who took the Browns out of Cleveland, but his legacy as one of the NFL's most influential personalities extends far beyond state lines. As an old-guard owner, he helped pour the foundation for today's game and...

    A championship-caliber idea for Big Ten title games

    A championship-caliber idea for Big Ten title games
    Too bad Mike Tirico does not get a vote. The ABC/ESPN play-by-play man has a dynamic proposal for the Big Ten championship game. “I would combine the old with the new, indoors and outdoors, and move it around the Midwest,” he said by...