Capitol Journal: Parks vs. ballot box budgeting

The debate about Prop. 21 is complex, and there are two legitimate points of view.

From Sacramento

California's magnificent state parks are falling apart fast.

The budgeting system for state government is in shambles and practically dysfunctional.

Proposition 21 on the November ballot would fix the parks. But it would pound another kink into budgeting for the rest of government. Or maybe not.

This one is tough. And as with most tough policy issues, simplistic rhetoric doesn't get to the real crux of the matter.

Yes, we all love parks -- some of us more than others, but no one wants to see them continue to deteriorate. The issue isn't the glory of parks. It's who pays to save them. And who decides.

And yes, ballot box budgeting is a scourge of state governing. It reduces the flexibility of the governor and the Legislature to act. But if they're incapable of acting, should the voters then solve the problem themselves?

Besides, Prop. 21 is sort of benign ballot box budgeting because it would generate a new revenue source to pay for its spending proposal. It wouldn't merely lock up a chunk of the state General Fund, as previous ballot initiatives have.

"This would have been easier to pass if it just said the Legislature must spend $300 million a year on parks," says Joe Caves, campaign coordinator for Prop. 21. "But that's ballot box budgeting. We're letting the voters decide whether they want to pay additional for parks."

Prop. 21 would impose an $18 surcharge on vehicle registration, except for commercial vehicles and trailers. In return, the vehicles would be entitled to free day-use entry and parking at state parks. Fees could still be charged for tours and overnight camping.

The surcharge would generate about $500 million annually. All of that would have to be spent on operating, maintaining and repairing state parks (85% of it) and protecting other wildlife and natural resources (15%).

But Prop. 21 actually would give the Legislature more flexibility over the deficit-plagued General Fund. That's because lawmakers could "back out" -- in budget speak -- the roughly $140 million in General Fund money currently being spent on parks and allocate those dollars to other programs, such as education and healthcare.

In all, after subtracting the loss of General Fund money and vehicle entry fees, state parks and wildlife programs would come out at least $250 million ahead annually, the legislative analyst calculates.

Backing the ballot initiative are the private California State Parks Foundation and a long list of environmental organizations and activists. They've raised roughly $5 million and have banked enough for TV ads, Caves says.

There's only token opposition, primarily from the automobile manufacturers lobby. The automakers feel they're being unjustly picked on.

"They're tired of all these nickel and dime car taxes," says Rob Stutzman, a strategist for the lobby, called the Auto Alliance. "They're not opposed to vehicle fees, but they want them connected to funding transportation.

"If this passes, where does it end? Does the teachers union come up with a $50 fee for schools?"

Actually, the vehicle license fee -- the controversial "car tax" -- funds all types of local government services. The smaller vehicle registration fee does help pay for the DMV and CHP.

Eugene F. Erbin, Sacramento lobbyist for the automakers, says: "We're not opposed to parks. But we don't want to be the easiest target."

The automakers, however, don't oppose Prop. 21 enough to spend much money fighting it. They've put up less than $50,000 and plan no advertising.

News Coverage on Cincinnati Reds - CTNow
RSS feeds allow Web site content to be gathered via feed reader software. Click the subscribe link to obtain the feed URL for this page. The feed will update when new content appears on this page.

Cincinnati Reds

A collection of news and information related to Cincinnati Reds published by this site and its partners.

Top Cincinnati Reds Articles see all

Displaying items 1-5
  • Covering Paul Konerko: Reporters' remembrances

    Covering Paul Konerko: Reporters' remembrances
    Colleen Kane
  • Gene Collier: No shame in staying home for Pirates

    The very best baseball summer in the history of PNC Park ended pretty much the way it began here Sunday, with a tense 1-0 victory against a divisional opponent, the first on an extra-inning home run by Neil Walker way back on March 31, the last when...

    Simon's 15-win season a pleasant surprise for Reds

    The Sports Xchange MLB Team Report - Cincinnati Reds - INSIDE PITCH ST. LOUIS -- The Cincinnati Reds, who were expected to contend for the National League Central title, are closing out a disappointing season. They collapsed after the All-Star break and...

    Loss has Brewers all but eliminated from postseason

    The Sports Xchange MLB Team Report - Milwaukee Brewers - INSIDE PITCH PITTSBURGH -- Once again, the Milwaukee Brewers were close to taking a key victory that would keep them in the thick of the playoff chase. But with Sunday's 1-0 loss to the Pittsburgh...

    Cardinals fall to Reds after clinching playoff berth

    Cardinals fall to Reds after clinching playoff berth ST. LOUIS -- For the fourth consecutive year, St. Louis is heading to the postseason. However, the Cardinals missed a chance Sunday night to reduce their magic number for a second straight...