The Parrot Heads of Penzance are back for another warm winter

THEATER REVIEW: "The Pirates of Penzance" by The Hypcrites at Chopin Theatre ★★★½

  • Pin It
  Ryan Bourque, Shawn Pfautsch, Zeke Sulkes, Doug Pawlik and Matt Kahler in "The Pirates of Penzance."

Ryan Bourque, Shawn Pfautsch, Zeke Sulkes, Doug Pawlik and Matt Kahler in "The Pirates of Penzance." (November 28, 2011)

A tiki bar serving mai tais and the like has been added to The Hypocrites' production of "The Pirates of Penzance," back for a second winter. The ability to imbibe, mid-show and for a mere five-spot, a fruity cocktail with a little umbrella is, perhaps, the final cherry on the top of director Sean Graney's wacky but supremely joyous little tribute to W.S. Gilbert and Arthur Sullivan's famously scurvy musical tale of dutiful orphans and their simpering amours, not to mention comic coppers and that most modern of Major-Generals.

The concrete corner of Division Street and Milwaukee and Ashland Avenues is a brutalist triangular intersection not exactly known for its warm, lapping breezes and bucolic sunsets, so be assured that that the booze in the blender is located indoors, in the basement of the Chopin Theatre. It's all part of Graney's inspired conceit that takes this 19th century operetta (or the good bits, anyway) and mixes it with a kind of "Beach Blanket Babylon" conceit, all performed on a go-where-you-want set (the work of Tom Burch) that resembles nothing so much as the set of "Mamma Mia!" combined with the decor of one of Jimmy Buffett's Margaritaville restaurants. Well, it's a bit classier than that, but you get the idea. The witty lighting design from Jared Moore is not so much a lighting concept as an attempt to assuage seasonal affective disorder, which, let me tell you, is one very real disorder in my particular head. And the first snow has yet to fly.

Unless you are a Gilbert-and-Sullivan purist incapable of understanding that authentic Victorian topsy-turveydom will survive long after Graney, it's hard not to have big-time fun at this carnival of a "Pirates," which lands in one of rare but sweet spots where a fairly outlandish off-Loop conceit meshes deliciously with the original material. Certainly, this 85-minute affair does not contain every last word of Gilbert's libretto — it's all the famous songs, plus enough connective tissue to tell the story. But I felt the same way as when I saw the 90-minute "Phantom of the Opera" in Las Vegas — didn't miss the other 90 minutes for as second.

Graney's secret ingredient here is Kevin O'Donnell's hilarious orchestrations, which involve playing those public-domain Sullivan ditties on a variety of stringed instruments, ranging from violins to acoustic guitars to ukuleles, often played from inside a plastic swimming pool. This multi-stringed sound has an amusingly driven quality that not only pokes a little fun at Parrot Heads and all they hold dear, but consistently makes you laugh, even as it gives new life to Sullivan's famous toe-tapping melodies, with which this particular show is especially well stocked.

» The latest on traffic, delays and road construction delivered to your mobile phone. Click to sign up to receive text alerts!

The casting is similarly amusing — the ranks of General Stanley's daughters are reduced to three, who double as the police. And better yet, Graney doubles the roles of Mabel and Ruth, which has the added benefit of reducing the inherent ageism of the original plot. "Are you Ruth or Mabel?" the actress Christine Stulik is asked. "I have no idea," she says, truthfully enough, to fits of laughter.

As was the case last year, the show is cast with exuberant young actors and musicians whose singing ranges from passable to pretty decent. Only the splendid Matt Kahler, who plays Major General Stanley, comes with the full compliment of Gilbert-and-Sullivan technique, including a skill with a patter song that could rival any light-opera outfit. And you can hear Shawn Pfautsch's fine voice coming through in the ensemble. But other than that, you have to make some allowances, though the music was much tighter this year and it was clear that all involved had been working hard on nailing the various ditties. It is no great sacrifice.

I still think this truly terrific conception would be yet funnier with a full compliment of operetta-trained singers, and it would not surprise me if it gets exported from Chicago that way, but the lovable local troupers here nearly bust a collective gasket getting into the spirits of things and offering a little spring break amid a Chicago winter.


When: Through Jan. 22

Where: Chopin Theatre, 1543 W. Division St.

Running time: 1 hour, 25 minutes

Tickets: $28-$36 at 773-989-7352 or

  • Pin It
News Coverage on Hunting - CTNow
RSS feeds allow Web site content to be gathered via feed reader software. Click the subscribe link to obtain the feed URL for this page. The feed will update when new content appears on this page.


A collection of news and information related to Hunting published by this site and its partners.

Top Hunting Articles

Displaying items 23-33
  • Orchid loss in Md. mountains laid to deer

    Orchid loss in Md. mountains laid to deer
    For as long as anyone can remember, wild orchids have rewarded sharp-eyed hikers in Maryland's Catoctin Mountains with pink, yellow and white blooms peeping from the forest floor. But these "secret beauties," as one researcher dubbed them, are vanishing...
  • 'Do Not Sell at Any Price's' hunters stalk rare 78 rpm records

    'Do Not Sell at Any Price's' hunters stalk rare 78 rpm records
    Midway through her thoughtful, entertaining history of obsessed music collectors and their quest for rare early 78 rpm records, writer Amanda Petrusich has a revelation. Focusing on one particular seeker and his knack for finding obscure titles others...
  • Founder of Mr. Goodcents chain builds an outdoors paradise in Kansas

    MAPLETON, Kan. Joe Bisogno bounced down a rugged path in his ATV until he reached a scenic vista of the paradise he has built in southeast Kansas. "If I would blindfold you and bring you here, you would never guess you were in Kansas," said Bisogno, 54,...
  • Slew of new laws hit Virginia's books

    Slew of new laws hit Virginia's books
    RICHMOND — Hundreds of new laws take effect Tuesday, and you probably won't notice most of them. But one would have caught just about everyone's attention if it hadn't gone into effect: The new state budget. It directs $96 billion in state and...
  • Kate MacFall: Bear hunt is no way to alleviate problem

    In response to recent conflicts between bears and humans in Central Florida, some legislators have suggested the Sunshine State needs to implement a trophy hunt on the unique and rare Florida black bear — a subspecies of the American black bear....
  • The last living Nazis

     The last living Nazis
    Johann Breyer appeared in a Philadelphia courtroom recently to face accusations that he assisted in the murder of thousands of Jews as a guard at the Nazi concentration camp at Auschwitz. He has been charged by German authorities with 158 counts of...
  • Northern California man fined for poaching, skinning 60 bobcats, foxes

    Northern California man fined for poaching, skinning 60 bobcats, foxes
    A Northern California man has pleaded guilty to illegally poaching 60 bobcats and gray foxes for their pelts, snaring them in traps he set over 900 square miles in two counties, officials said. Tracy Lee Shultz of Courtland, south of Sacramento, was...
  • Academy Invites 271 New Members

    The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences has invited 271 individuals to become members, with the list reflecting the org's determination to bring more diversity to its ranks. Every year, the list of invitations includes several recent Oscar...
  • A full list of Academy member invitees

    A full list of Academy member invitees
    Invitations were sent to 271 individuals to join the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences on Thursday. They gain entry to the academy by earning an Oscar nomination, by getting two members to pen recommendations or by receiving an endorsement...
  • Ann McFeatters: Ivory ban exemptions needed

    WASHINGTON As I gaze at my computer mouse pad, a rubbery version of Monet's "Water Lilies," I keep seeing the number 54. As in million. As in how much an anonymous American just paid for the original, painted in 1906. Of course, that's far below the...
  • Bass supply the essence of angling

    GORDON, Wis. Mike Jaszczak caught the first largemouth bass of the day. He held it up for us to admire. It was a beauty mottled in the colors of summer, with the outsized mouth and the deep green stripe along its flank. It was a good 3 inches long....