'Her' review: Siri-ously wonderful

RedEye's Matt Pais and Ernest Wilkins discuss Martin Scorsese's amusing but shallow 3-hour comedy and Spike Jonze's 4-star look at personal and technological connection.

**** (out of four)

At BeautifulHandwrittenLetters.com, Theodore (Joaquin Phoenix) pours out someone else's heart, using submitted photos and e-communication to craft anniversary cards and more. He speaks to the computer, the program writes in lovely handwriting and a decades-long love is sustained and honored by a third party.

Lack of interpersonal connection in the Internet and smartphone age has become an onscreen cliche (and the driving force behind this year's "Disconnect" with Jason Bateman), but writer-director Spike Jonze's "Her" is an original voice among the noise. It's one of the funniest and saddest movies of the year. That twofer doesn't happen often.

Unable to sign papers finalizing his divorce from Catherine (Rooney Mara), Theodore lives inside memories of their playfulness and closeness -- recollections that can't help but be interrupted by shards of arguments and regret. Then he buys a new, artificially intelligent operating system named Samantha (voiced by Scarlett Johansson), and everything changes. Samantha is like Siri 10.0: She organizes and assists. She edits Theodore's letters. She also engages and grows. Yet she's not programmed to abide like a robot; when Samantha and Theodore bond, it's like the closeness of a relationship over the phone. When they eventually take things to a sexual place, her lack of a body doesn't change the fact that their intimacy is as different as night and day compared to his previous experience paying for phone sex. Samantha has no physical presence, but she is Theodore's girlfriend, capable of jealousy ... and being carried around in a pocket.

Clearly, "Her" requires an acceptance of Jonze's vision (no, he doesn't address the legality of marrying your OS) that we've become so technologically dependent, this product isn't out of the question eventually, and some people would be thrilled for non-prurient reasons. The entire cast, including Amy Adams as Theodore's pal Amy and Olivia Wilde as a woman whose blind date with Theodore goes great until suddenly it doesn't, connects beautifully. They all exist in the same universe of distracted dissatisfaction. Jonze presents video games in particular with a hilarious skepticism; Amy works on a game in which the player attempts to be the perfect mother, modeling behavior after what technology, as written by a person, dictates is proper.

Other than juicy celeb images and convenience, what do we get and we do we search for in our gadgets? What's missing in our offline relationships? In the gorgeous, strange world of "Her," the act of people living and feeling together practically comes into competition with a revolution for which no one was prepared.

Watch Matt on “You & Me This Morning,” Friday at 6:55 a.m. on WCIU, the U



Want more? Discuss this article and others on RedEye's Facebook page.


Featured Stories

CTnow is using Facebook comments on stories. To comment on ctnow.com articles, sign into Facebook and enter your comment in the field below. Comments will appear in your Facebook News Feed unless you choose otherwise. To report spam or abuse, click the X next to the comment. For guidelines on commenting, click here.
News Coverage on The Wire (tv program) - CTNow
RSS feeds allow Web site content to be gathered via feed reader software. Click the subscribe link to obtain the feed URL for this page. The feed will update when new content appears on this page.

The Wire (tv program)

A collection of news and information related to The Wire (tv program) published by this site and its partners.

Top The Wire (tv program) Articles

Displaying items 67-77
  • Artful 'Leftovers' on HBO leaves viewers wanting more

     Artful 'Leftovers' on HBO leaves viewers wanting more
    HBO's latest Quality Entertainment, "The Leftovers," arrives Sunday. Developed by Damon Lindelof ("Lost") and Tom Perrotta from Perrotta's 2011 novel, it is set in a New York small town three years after the sudden disappearance of 2% of the world's...
  • FrightFest to Open with 'Guest,' Starring 'Downton' Star Dan Stevens

    LONDON -- Adam Wingard's killer thriller "The Guest," starring "Downton Abbey" star Dan Stevens and rising thesp Maika Monroe ("The Bling Ring," "It Follows"), is set to open Film4 FrightFest in London. The film, written by Simon Barrett ("You're Next,"...
  • 50 Cent Sent Ideas for Starz' 'Power' With Lots of LOLs and Emojis

    Manhattan's Highline Ballroom was re-adorned Monday night as Truth, the pivotal club of Starz's new primetime drama "Power." Deep into his entourage, executive producer and co-star Curtis "50 Cent" Jackson grinned from the balcony as he fielded salutes...
  • 3 Chicago actors cast in 'Wire' creator's newest project for HBO

    3 Chicago actors cast in 'Wire' creator's newest project for HBO
    A trio of actors with deep Chicago ties have been added to the cast of the HBO mini-series "Show Me a Hero," the latest project from David Simon. Longtime TV actor Jim Belushi, Steppenwolf co-founder Terry Kinney and Lakeview native and Columbia College...
  • 'Fargo' star Allison Tolman is having quite a year

    'Fargo' star Allison Tolman is having quite a year
    August 2013: Chicago actress Allison Tolman, unemployed and doing temp work in the mornings, stops by her agent's office to tape an audition for the new FX series "Fargo." August 2014: Tolman is headed to the Emmys. That's quite a 12-month span....
  • The Showrunner Must Go On

    The late Aaron Spelling was modest and courtly to a fault. So when asked about his storied career at the TV Critics Assn. tour years ago, he gave most of the credit to the actors, writers and artisans with whom he'd worked. When a rather naive reporter...
  • 1991's 'A Rage in Harlem' and other films at the Black Harvest Film Fest

    1991's 'A Rage in Harlem' and other films at the Black Harvest Film Fest
    Hitting its 20th anniversary milestone this year, the Black Harvest Film Festival runs through the month of August at the Gene Siskel Film Center, spotlighting black cinema. The fest hasn't always been especially discerning about quality. I'm not sure...
  • 'Wire' actor stabbed inside Washington nightclub

    'Wire' actor stabbed inside Washington nightclub
    Anwan Glover, who appeared in three seasons of "The Wire," was stabbed inside a Washington D.C. nightclub early Sunday, police said. About 2 a.m. Sunday, a man approached Glover inside the Cafe Asia nightclub in the 1700 block of I Street in Northwest...
  • 'The Wire' Actor Anwan Glover Stabbed at D.C. Nightclub

    Actor Anwan Glover, best known for his role in HBO series "The Wire," suffered a laceration on the right side of his torso after being punched, kicked and stabbed in Washington D.C., according to a police report obtained by the Washington Post. According...
  • Hosting baseball's All-Star Game in 2016 would boost the Orioles, city of Baltimore

    Hosting baseball's All-Star Game in 2016 would boost the Orioles, city of Baltimore
    When baseball commissioner Bud Selig said recently that Baltimore was a "very, very viable candidate" to host the 2016 All-Star Game at Camden Yards, those who have sought for the Midsummer Classic's return to the city for years received a boost to...
  • This ain't livin' [Commentary]

    This ain't livin' [Commentary]
    To paraphrase Marvin Gaye's "Inner City Blues," it makes you want to holler, the way so many people in Baltimore do their lives. Dying is too easy in this city, and neither death nor we should be proud. Even before summer officially arrives, nearly 90...