The blowback of the surprising swap even reached as far as Colts coach Chuck Pagano's cellphone. Text messages piled up from former players, including from the division where the former Ravens defensive coordinator used to coach.
"All I know is, I got a couple texts from some players I used to coach and it was, 'Wow, congrats and thank you,'" Pagano said during Richardson's introductory news conference Thursday. "And you know why they said, 'Thank you' — because he's out of the division. That tells you right there: He's a game wrecker."
Richardson, the No. 3 overall selection in the 2012 draft who finished with 950 rushing yards in an injury-plagued rookie season, certainly is not Willis McGahee. The Browns (0-2) signed the 31-year-old Thursday to a one-year contract as a stopgap measure, and the former Ravens running back could face his old team in November.
For the Browns' new regime of CEO Joe Banner and coach Rob Chudzinski, the trade is seen as a clear indictment of former team president Mike Holmgren and general manager Tom Heckert.
It's also viewed as a sign that, by trading arguably its best offensive player, the organization already has abandoned any hopes of a winning season.
Let go last season, Holmgren ripped the trade.
"I struggled with it," Holmgren, who traded up to acquire Richardson, told Seattle radio station KGR. "How do you make your team better by trading your best player? He's a valuable, valuable guy.
"To me, they're putting all their eggs for next season. They started off 0-2, they couldn't score any points. I think it was a knee-jerk reaction."
Banner defended the trade Friday, and avoided getting into a back-and-forth with a combustible Holmgren, who traded fourth, fifth and seventh-round picks last year to the Minnesota Vikings to move up to pick Richardson.
“Mike’s entitled to his opinion,” Banner said. “He ran the team for three years and was able to do what he believed in. It’s our turn trying to do what we think is right. Obviously wouldn’t have done this if we agreed with his comments.”
And Banner refuted the notion that Chudzinski was against the trade, which should net a pick in the bottom third of the first round considering the Colts drafted 24th overall last season when they finished
11-5 and made the playoffs.
“I think the most important thing for me to say is we don’t do anything with Chud not right in the middle of every discussion, every evaluation,'' Banner said. "Every single time I got off the phone with (Colts general manager) Ryan Grigson I went down, reported to him where we’re at. He’s a very strong believer in where we’re at and where we’re headed and how this is going to help us.
"I think the most important thing is for people to realize we’re all on the same page. This is a collaborative decision that everybody in the organization, from the owner, myself, the head coach,
everybody involved felt very strongly was a good thing to do.”
The Colts hope Richardson, who was held to 58 rushing yards in a 14-6 loss to the Ravens last Sunday, can replace injured starter Vick Ballard (knee) and add balance to an offense led by quarterback Andrew Luck.
Richardson will still face questions in Indianapolis. Reports about his supposed immaturity have dogged the former Alabama star, and he apologized last season after publicly questioning former coach Pat Shurmur's play calling.
Richardson said at his introductory news conference that his shock over the trade is "starting to wear off, but it's still a shock. At the same time, I'm ready to open up this new chapter in life and I'm going to have a chip on my shoulder."
Richardson also urged Browns fans not to give up hope.
“For Browns fans, keep rooting for the Browns," he said. " Don’t give up on them. When they get over
that hill, it’s going to happen. They got a program that’s going to go in a good direction.
"With the fans, I hated leaving Cleveland. I love Cleveland, loved being around them. But like I said, I’m here starting a new chapter of my life.”