ELMONT, N.Y. — In the end, California Chrome could not outrun recent history.
All week, veteran horsemen had pointed to the 11/2-mile oval at Belmont Park, the longest in American thoroughbred racing, and predicted it would be the grueling expanse on which his Triple Crown quest withered. They had seen it too many times, brilliantly fast horses losing their juice down the stretch of the Belmont Stakes.
Surely this son of a sluggish filly and an unremarkable stallion would falter, just as Big Brown and Smarty Jones and Silver Charm had in the 36 years before him. It wasn't the result most in racing wanted, but the skeptics' logic held.
- At Pimlico Race Course, big bets and disappointment for California Chrome bettors
- As 'Chrome' falls, chorus of Triple Crown critics rises
- 28-1 long shot Commissioner comes up just short in Belmont
- Preakness Stakes 2014
- Preakness 2014 infield pictures and photos of the party scene
- Preakness week 2014
See more photos »
- Horse Racing
- Triple Crown
- Preakness Stakes
See more topics »
Running his third race in five weeks, California Chrome never could find his usual burst of speed Saturday. He finished tied for fourth behind the victorious, and fresher, Tonalist and joined a list of 12 others who've fallen one victory short of becoming the first Triple Crown winner since Affirmed in 1978.
His defeat surely will fuel debates about the very nature of the Triple Crown, with many, including California Chrome's owners and trainer, arguing that the three-race test is no longer fair. Co-owner Steve Coburn called it a “coward's way out” to run fresh horses in the third leg of the Triple Crown.
Long before Saturday, Coburn and trainer Art Sherman had advocated for longer breaks between the races. Coburn also argued that the Preakness and Belmont Stakes should be closed to horses who haven't run the previous legs. A Triple Crown aspirant, he said, shouldn't have to face an armada of refreshed horses at the end of his quest.
Such challengers, known as fresh shooters, have dominated the Belmont in recent years, often beating seemingly superior horses who won the Kentucky Derby and Preakness.
Tonalist owner Robert Evans declined to comment on Coburn's suggestion that horses such as his shouldn't be allowed to run in the Belmont. But he did come out in support of longer breaks between the races.
“It would be a little bit better for the horses,” he said. “And it would give us more time to promote it.”
Others spoke for tradition, saying the Triple Crown is supposed to be this grueling a test. “We'll see another Triple Crown winner,” said Dale Romans, owner of third-place finisher Medal Count. “You don't make things easier just because it hasn't been done.”
Tonalist was the ninth straight Belmont winner not to have run in the Preakness, and Evans had a unique perspective for his feat: His father, Thomas Mellon Evans, owned Pleasant Colony, who lost a 1981 Triple Crown bid in the Belmont, and Tonalist is Pleasant Colony's grandson.
“I came to the Belmont in 1981 with high hopes for Pleasant Colony,” he recalled. “I've been where Steve Coburn's been, and it's not fun when you don't win. It was very quiet after he didn't win.”
It was the second Belmont disappointment for California Chrome's jockey, Victor Espinoza, who finished eighth aboard War Emblem in 2002 after wins in the Kentucky Derby and Preakness. He kept California Chrome slightly off the pace, as he had in other races, but never felt the chestnut colt had a big move in him.
“I noticed something as soon as he came out of the gate,” Espinoza said. “He was not the same.”
Afterward, trainers tended to California Chrome’s front right hoof, which he reportedly cut coming out of the gate.
California Chrome's near-miss story surely will overshadow Tonalist's triumph, which came in just his fifth career race. The colt missed a shot at qualifying for the Kentucky Derby because he was ill, and did not show his true potential until he won the May 10 Peter Pan Stakes at Belmont Park. He was the first horse to start a Triple Crown race for Evans, who owns 500-acre Courtland Farm in Easton.
The 70-year-old owner was visibly moved after the race, describing how he visited his father's grave in Connecticut the day before. “I just thanked him for putting me in position to do this,” he said.
Tonalist went off as a 9-1 choice and paid $20.40 for the win, $9.60 to place and $7 to show. Second-place finisher Commissioner paid $23.20 and $13.20. Medal Count paid $13.20.
The loss in the $1.5 million Belmont brought a gloomy conclusion to one of the great populist tales in recent thoroughbred history. California Chrome was the hero of the little guy, a horse of unremarkable pedigree whose owners — a California businessman and Nevada manufacturing worker — paid a modest $10,000 to breed him. With his versatile speed, chestnut color and four white stockings, he evoked many great champions, including the most popular of them all, Secretariat.
Fans packed the massive grandstand at Belmont Park, roaring when California Chrome stepped onto the track. Many waved “Triple Chrome” signs in the horse's purple-and-green color scheme. Some even wore “Chrome” nasal strips to mimic their hero's famous bit of equipment.