December 3, 2009
The Details: Madonna has never been shy about sex, and ARod is no stranger to scandal. So perhaps it shouldn't be surprising when rumors started to fly that these superstars from the worlds of music and baseball hooked up. The details are sketchy, but we do know that at about the time of the alleged affair, Madge dumped director Guy Ritchie, her hubby of 8 years, and Cynthia Rodriguez sued ARod for divorce, claiming emotional abandonment and marital misconduct. As the slugger theoretically hooked up with the singer when Cynthia was dealing with the birth of their second daughter, we hope she got a massive divorce settlement.