'Smart meters' may soon be outdated

That's the idea anyway. The reality, at least as far as California utilities are concerned, is that the coming smart meters will do little more than save the companies money by allowing them to read customers' meters remotely -- thus enabling them to fire their meter readers.

The new meters also will allow utilities to connect or disconnect service remotely, saving them the expense of sending a technician to your home.

Experts say it's unlikely that the utilities would be able to provide real-time pricing info to millions of customers without broadband connections.

They also say that lower-speed meters could clog existing bandwidth with trouble reports during an outage, preventing utilities from getting an accurate fix on the scope of a problem or where to send repair crews.

The utilities counter that customers will be able to enjoy full smart-grid capabilities as long as they have a separate broadband Internet connection. For those who don't, sorry.

"We think this is the best way to serve our customers," said Anne Shen Smith, senior vice president of customer service at San Diego Gas & Electric, which is spending $570 million to roll out 1.4 million new meters by 2011.

"We can put these meters in now and give you immediate benefits," she said. "Then we'll look at incremental benefits down the road and translate that into what it means for rates and costs."

In other words, SDG&E and the other utilities will upgrade or even replace their meters once they see how much consumers want all the capabilities that come with a broadband smart grid.

"It wouldn't surprise me if there isn't more functionality we want to install down the road," said Jana Corey, director of Pacific Gas & Electric's smart meter program. The San Francisco-based utility is spending $2.3 billion to install 10.3 million new meters by 2011.

Californians could end up having to pay twice to get to the smart-grid future that state and federal officials have already decreed to be our goal. This would be profitable for the utilities, which stand to gain additional revenue with each meter upgrade, but very expensive for ratepayers.

"Once you deploy these new meters, it will be very, very hard to upgrade them," said Robert Robinson, a vice president at consulting firm Booz Allen Hamilton who specializes in electric utilities.

"No one knows what all the futuristic applications will be," he said. "You want to be thinking about the endgame for all the things that will connect to the grid through your meter. All of that will require bandwidth."

It's possible, of course, that the cost of broadband meters will come down in the future, and that waiting to upgrade makes more economic sense. Similarly, not all ratepayers may want the full functionality of a broadband meter.

But if the growth of the Internet tells us anything, it's that it's better to be technologically prepared for all the bells and whistles that come with advanced data networks. Chances are, it'll be cheaper over the long run to bring consumers up to speed now, rather than waiting to upgrade their meters in the future.

Is it too late for the utilities to shift gears? No. Thousands of new meters have already been installed in pilot programs, but millions more have yet to make it to people's homes.

Terrie Prosper, a spokeswoman for the California Public Utilities Commission, said the new meters met performance standards set by regulators.

But she acknowledged that "to be cost-effective, the systems implemented by the utilities are less sophisticated and less expensive than a broadband system."

It seems incredibly shortsighted to build a high-speed network for utilities that consumers will be able to access only through lower-speed meters. State regulators need to take a closer look at this situation and determine what's best for the state as a whole, not just the utilities.

Otherwise, a few years from now, we could have the dumbest smart grid in the country.

Consumer Confidential runs Wednesdays and Sundays. Send your tips or feedback to david.lazarus@latimes.com.

Featured Stories

CTnow is using Facebook comments on stories. To comment on ctnow.com articles, sign into Facebook and enter your comment in the field below. Comments will appear in your Facebook News Feed unless you choose otherwise. To report spam or abuse, click the X next to the comment. For guidelines on commenting, click here.


Kevin Hunt - The Electronic Jungle

Kevin Hunt: Wanna-Haves For The Tailgater - August 8, 2014 - Back-to-school season usually doesn't deserve a celebration, except by some parents, but it coincides with two other seasons —...

Gail MarksJarvis

Take steps to limit damage if hackers snare your data - August 29, 2014 - You might have gone to a supermarket, mailed a package at UPS or gone to a restaurant or hospital and thought nothing about holding your...

David Lazarus

Why isn't your pay-TV bill reduced when a channel is removed? - August 28, 2014 - Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti stepped up to the plate in the Great Dodgers Blackout this week, calling on federal regulators to look...

Korky Vann

Books Inspiring Global Tours, Journeys - August 3, 2014 - Book lovers who head out to visit authors' homes, museums and gravesites are part of a new chapter in travel called "literary tourism."