AT&T Mobile Insurance customer contract terms ring hollow

Sneaky provisions buried in AT&T's wireless device coverage contract trip up a customer seeking to file a claim on her stolen iPhone.


AT&T Mobile Insurance, which costs customers $6.99 a month, is said to provide coverage for wireless devices in case of loss, theft or accidental damage. (Justin Sullivan, Getty Images / March 3, 2014)

There are a lot of really unfriendly consumer contracts out there.

But the absurdly worded terms and conditions for AT&T Mobile Insurance, the company's coverage for wireless devices, take corporate meanness to a whole new level.

Marianna Yarovskaya thought she was being smart when she recently purchased AT&T's insurance to safeguard the new iPhone 5S she bought before an overseas trip.

"With AT&T Mobile Insurance," the company's website says, "you can protect your investment and get a replacement device quickly to keep you connected."

ASK LAZ: Smart answers to consumer questions


Yarovskaya, 42, of Hollywood, agreed to have $6.99 added each month to her wireless bill for the peace of mind that comes with knowing she was covered in case of loss, theft or accidental damage.

She should have saved her money.

Not only did AT&T and its partner, an insurance provider called Asurion, bury the most weaselly of provisions in their contract, they did so using language not even a master cryptographer could have deciphered.

While on the trip to Indonesia in January to research a documentary film, Yarovskaya's iPhone was stolen from her hotel. She filed a report with the local police and then submitted a claim with Asurion.

"They denied the claim," Yarovskaya told me. "And then I submitted another claim and they denied that too. And then a third one."

An Asurion rep explained to Yarovskaya that because she was outside AT&T's network when she signed up for coverage — she had enrolled while on the Indonesian trip, using her hotel's Wi-Fi connection — she wasn't entitled to a replacement phone.

"This is crazy," Yarovskaya said. "They are saying that if you travel, the insurance becomes worthless."

Actually, that's not quite what they're saying. The problem is how they're saying what they're really saying.

When Yarovskaya signed up for AT&T Mobile Insurance, Asurion emailed her nine pages of terms and conditions — the sort of linguistic briar patch few people attempt to traverse.

Had she taken the time to read it, though, it's entirely possible that Yarovskaya would have come away with the impression that all was well anyway.

Under "eligibility," for example, on the sixth of the document's nine pages, it states that "covered property must be actively registered on the service provider's network on the date of loss and have logged airtime prior to the date of loss."

No worries. Yarovskaya had purchased the iPhone and started service with AT&T before departing Los Angeles. She was thus "actively registered" with the carrier at the time her phone went missing.

On the seventh page of the terms, under "additional conditions," the insurer states that "the coverage territory is worldwide," although the cost of any replacement or repair will be valued in U.S. currency.

So far so good. The clear impression up to this point is that if you're already registered with a wireless provider, you're covered anywhere you go.

Featured Stories

CTnow is using Facebook comments on stories. To comment on articles, sign into Facebook and enter your comment in the field below. Comments will appear in your Facebook News Feed unless you choose otherwise. To report spam or abuse, click the X next to the comment. For guidelines on commenting, click here.


Kevin Hunt - The Electronic Jungle

Kevin Hunt: Belkin's WeMo Crock-Pot, the smart slow cooker - December 1, 2014 - I will not defend a Wi-Fi-connected can opener, doorbell or toaster, but I will defend almost everything about Belkin's Crock-Pot Smart...

Gail MarksJarvis

1st quarter ends with stocks down, disappointment over economy - March 31, 2015 - The first quarter has come to an end with analysts much less certain about the strength of the economy than they were late in 2014 and the...

David Lazarus

It's fun to be a billionaire -- just ask a billionaire - March 3, 2015 - Here's what went down on Tuesday's Consumer Confidential segment on KTLA-TV:

Korky Vann

NY, Boston, Philly Art Institutions Gear Up For Major Shows - March 26, 2015 - Spring doesn't just bring May flowers, it brings blockbuster shows at museums throughout the Northeast and this year is no exception....