Try the new, improved Hartford Courant digital edition today
CT Now

Nuclear waste can't wait

Federal law requires the government to identify a site or sites for nuclear waste.

In the 1957 Isaac Asimov short story "Silly Asses," Earthlings are added to a galactic book of planetary races that have reached maturity — defined as those that have developed nuclear capability. But then the keeper of the book learns that atomic tests are being conducted on Earth and crosses the planet off the list. Asimov was writing during the A-bomb years, before the construction of nuclear power plants. How unacceptable would it seem to the fictional keeper of the book that we have been building and operating these reactors for decades without a place to store the waste?

Last week, a federal appeals court ordered the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to move forward on either granting or denying a permit for an underground nuclear waste site at Yucca Mountain. The Obama administration had put the brakes on the permit process, fulfilling a campaign promise to Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.), who doesn't want the spent fuel in his home state.

Yucca Mountain is one of the safest places in the country for nuclear storage. It's a remote, dry area that isn't earthquake-prone, and it's on the edge of an area where atomic testing took place during the 1950s. But it's not without flaws, and one issue that never was resolved is transporting nuclear waste safely to this or any repository.

Federal law requires the government to identify a site or sites for nuclear waste. The list was narrowed during the George W. Bush administration to Yucca Mountain. That choice was too abrupt and too limited; for one thing, Yucca Mountain isn't large enough to be the sole repository. But the Obama administration's response — that it will work on finding multiple smaller sites in other states — circumvents the problem of disposal rather than confronting it. No state wants to be the dumping grounds for the nation's nuclear waste, but it has to go somewhere, and the problem won't solve itself.

The situation highlights a major flaw in the president's plan for relying on nuclear power as part of the effort to combat climate change. It's not a real plan when it doesn't make provisions for safe disposal. Existing and decommissioned plants have been storing their spent fuel on-site, either in pools or encased in concrete casks. It's an unacceptable situation. The casks, which will be used to store waste at the defunct San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station, can withstand even strong earthquakes, but their lifetime is measured in decades, while the waste will be dangerous for hundreds of thousands of years.

In other words, nuclear policy requires farsighted thinking. California law wisely prohibits the construction of new nuclear plants until a safe method has been devised for permanently disposing of waste. A mature federal energy policy would do the same.

Copyright © 2015, CT Now
Related Content
  • L.A.'s freeway-adjacent residents need more protection from pollution

    L.A.'s freeway-adjacent residents need more protection from pollution

    A growing body of research shows that living next to a freeway can significantly increase the risk of asthma, heart disease, pre-term births, reduced lung function in children and premature death. Yet Los Angeles continues to approve residential developments next to freeways without imposing strong...

  • Alaska mine would be a Bristol Bay disaster waiting to happen

    Alaska mine would be a Bristol Bay disaster waiting to happen

    President Obama's decision to permanently protect Alaska's Bristol Bay and adjacent lands from oil and gas drilling is so clearly the correct decision that the only objections will come from those whose sole interest is the welfare of those two energy industries.

  • Want to help the bee populations? Grow a variety of flowers

    Want to help the bee populations? Grow a variety of flowers

    The European honey bee was brought to this continent in the early 1600s, but not to pollinate crops. Rather, early settlers sought beeswax to make candles. Native bees, which are mostly solitary ground-dwellers, were effective pollinators but did not provide significant quantities of wax or honey.

  • Learning to love paying 10 cents more per gallon

    Learning to love paying 10 cents more per gallon

    California drivers have been delighted to see gasoline prices dropping lately, down more than a dollar a gallon since early summer. It's no mystery what's causing it: Crude oil prices have fallen steeply, lowering the cost for refiners that process crude into gasoline. In the competitive refining...

  • Reducing methane is a wise short-term win

    Reducing methane is a wise short-term win

    For too long, carbon dioxide has dominated the discussion of greenhouse gases; for the most part, it has been the discussion. That gas, emitted by the burning of fossil fuels, is, after all, the biggie in terms of volume. But this single-minded approach has meant that the so-called short-lived...

  • Gov. Jerry Brown's fracking problem

    Gov. Jerry Brown's fracking problem

    California Gov. Jerry Brown has done more to fight climate change than perhaps any other elected official in the United States. So what accounts for the environmentalists heckling him during speeches and planning to confront him Saturday at an Oakland March for Real Climate Leadership? One word:...

Comments
Loading
84°