Try the new, improved Hartford Courant digital edition today
CT Now

Beware the clear-cutters

Even before the embers from the Rim fire had stopped smoldering, the House of Representatives was using the catastrophic forest fire as an excuse to pass a harmful logging bill.

HR 1526, the so-called Restoring Healthy Forests for Healthy Communities Act written by Rep. Doc Hastings (R-Wash.), would mandate that logging more than double in national forests and would require foresters to show that they had met certain timber quotas without regard for whether the forests involved were habitats for threatened species or whether they were in supposedly protected roadless areas.

One of the reasons given for the bill is that taking more lumber out of forests would reduce the intensity of wildfires. But the ferocity of recent infernos such as the Rim fire that swept through the dense Stanislaus National Forest and parts of Yosemite National Park is largely the result of a century of strict fire suppression in which smaller, natural fires were extinguished before they were able to reduce vegetation and thus make larger fires less likely.

There are smart ways to allow increased logging on federal lands so that it not only benefits the timber industry but also reduces the risk of conflagrations. Large swaths of trees in the Western United States are being killed by insect pests, creating a plantation of dried-out fire fuel. That wood has commercial value, though, if it can be cut soon after dying. Current rules require timber companies to wait too long.

In addition, thinning live trees can reduce forest overgrowth and slow the spread of fires. That requires leaving the older, bigger trees, which are more resistant to fire, and taking out the younger, smaller ones that are less sought after by logging operations. Heavy thinning adjacent to towns would provide a buffer that could help protect lives and homes.

But the Restoring Healthy Forests legislation includes none of these. Nor does it recognize that logging practices have typically increased the risk of disastrous fires, because loggers have left treetops and other unmarketable parts on the ground. This dead "slash," as it's called, dries out and acts as tinder for future fires. The timber industry must be required to clean up after itself. And part of the proceeds should go to upgrade the U.S. Forest Service's firefighting equipment and to fund carefully planned and controlled burns.

In some areas of the country, environmentalists and the timber industry have formed talking groups to hammer out agreements that benefit both loggers and the forest. This bill would effectively kill off those efforts and replace them with a one-damaging-size-fits-all approach to forest management.

Copyright © 2015, CT Now
Related Content
  • L.A.'s freeway-adjacent residents need more protection from pollution

    L.A.'s freeway-adjacent residents need more protection from pollution

    A growing body of research shows that living next to a freeway can significantly increase the risk of asthma, heart disease, pre-term births, reduced lung function in children and premature death. Yet Los Angeles continues to approve residential developments next to freeways without imposing strong...

  • Alaska mine would be a Bristol Bay disaster waiting to happen

    Alaska mine would be a Bristol Bay disaster waiting to happen

    President Obama's decision to permanently protect Alaska's Bristol Bay and adjacent lands from oil and gas drilling is so clearly the correct decision that the only objections will come from those whose sole interest is the welfare of those two energy industries.

  • Want to help the bee populations? Grow a variety of flowers

    Want to help the bee populations? Grow a variety of flowers

    The European honey bee was brought to this continent in the early 1600s, but not to pollinate crops. Rather, early settlers sought beeswax to make candles. Native bees, which are mostly solitary ground-dwellers, were effective pollinators but did not provide significant quantities of wax or honey.

  • Learning to love paying 10 cents more per gallon

    Learning to love paying 10 cents more per gallon

    California drivers have been delighted to see gasoline prices dropping lately, down more than a dollar a gallon since early summer. It's no mystery what's causing it: Crude oil prices have fallen steeply, lowering the cost for refiners that process crude into gasoline. In the competitive refining...

  • Reducing methane is a wise short-term win

    Reducing methane is a wise short-term win

    For too long, carbon dioxide has dominated the discussion of greenhouse gases; for the most part, it has been the discussion. That gas, emitted by the burning of fossil fuels, is, after all, the biggie in terms of volume. But this single-minded approach has meant that the so-called short-lived...

  • Gov. Jerry Brown's fracking problem

    Gov. Jerry Brown's fracking problem

    California Gov. Jerry Brown has done more to fight climate change than perhaps any other elected official in the United States. So what accounts for the environmentalists heckling him during speeches and planning to confront him Saturday at an Oakland March for Real Climate Leadership? One word:...

Comments
Loading
81°