Try the new, improved Hartford Courant digital edition today
CT Now

What Need For Secrecy In Newtown Investigation?

Timely information about the Newtown tragedy would answer a horrified public's questions about murders of 27 people Dec. 14. It could also better guide the legislature as it makes policy choices in reaction to the crime.

Yet so far, lawmakers, the judiciary and law enforcement are doing the opposite of acting with more openness. Instead, they are clamping down. Their default reaction regarding what happened in Newtown is to use more secrecy, not less.

This trend must stop.

Awful as the details are, secrecy is a mistake. It ignites public worry. It prevents ordinary people who might know critical details from becoming law enforcement allies. Worse, secrecy feeds into the whispers of those conspiracy theorists who believe that the police have something to hide. It plays into the motives of the complete lunatics who spread the slander that this slaughter somehow never happened.

Excessive Secrecy

The closed-door approach started early.

After the murders, Danbury State's Attorney Stephen J. Sedensky asked Superior Court Judge John Blawie to seal five warrant applications and affidavits in the Newtown case for 90 days. Judge Blawie did. The warrants requested permission to search the home of murderer Adam Lanza and to search the car the shooter used to drive to Sandy Hook Elementary School.

In January, several newspapers asked that the warrants be opened, a reasonable request.

Mr. Sedensky's letter to the court asked that the warrants be sealed because "the investigation ... is still continuing and no arrests have been made and none are currently anticipated, but have not been ruled out."

The right of the public to see documents filed in court is always counterbalanced with a suspect's right to a fair trial. Yet in this case, the suspect is dead.

There's also an understandable reluctance to reveal details of a police investigation before a crime is solved. Again, with the shooter dead, it's hard to believe that information on a warrant application would jeopardize anything.

When a judge takes the drastic step of keeping information from the public, people deserve a reasoned explanation. Closing records by fiat is not merely high-handed. It erodes the public's faith in the Judicial Branch.

Superior Court Judge John F. Blawie didn't bother to spell out his decision to seal the warrants other than writing that "the state's interest in continuing nondisclosure substantially outweighs any right to public disclosure at this time."

That's not a reason. That's a conclusion.

The records should be released sooner, not later.

Copyright © 2015, CT Now
Related Content
  • Curbs On Guns Work Better Than Old Slogans

    The rhetorical failure of the week belonged to state Rep. Craig Miner who, in handing down the lame list of Republican proposals from a working group on gun violence, said, "We believe it's not the gun that kills the person. It's the person that actually kills the person. That sounds kind of cold,...

  • Boston Study Shows Gun Laws Do Work

    Harm Reduction: Study correlates gun laws with fewer deaths

  • Violent Video Game Bans Misguided

    Legislators' energies would be better spent pursuing other ways to curb gun violence

  • It's Time 'Pro-Life' Meant Gun Control

    Politicians usually talk about being pro-life when it comes to opposing abortion. As a Catholic who served as U.S. ambassador to the Vatican under President George H. W. Bush, I share a deep commitment to protecting the sanctity of life in the womb. But what about our children, teachers and neighbors...

  • Must Keep Moving On Gun Control

    Magazines, Checks: Assault Weapon Ban Not The Only Tool In The Box

  • Getting Control Of Guns For All Americans

    "If The Civil Rights era has to be mentioned at all in the current gun debate, it's that the U.S. would be safer if blacks had stayed at the back of the bus — without access to firearms."

  • Adding Counselors Will Make Schools Safer

    As a high school counselor and coach in West Hartford, I recently testified before our state legislators on how best to support Connecticut schools after the December tragedy in Newtown.

  • Focus On Gun Access, Not Gun Bans

    Who among us has not been moved by the unspeakable tragedy that was inflicted upon the children of Newtown, our very home at the National Shooting Sports Foundation? What can possibly heal the wounds, silence the anguished outcries and make rational discourse out of such a horrific act? The answer...