A city agency that oversees hundreds of millions of dollars of construction projects “grossly overstated” the amount paid out to certified minority contractors in 2009, according to a report issued today by the city’s top internal watchdog.
The Public Building Commission reported paying $89 million to certified minority-owned businesses two years ago, but a review of actual payments and certifications indicates those payments were overstated by nearly 40 percent, the report concludes.
Inspector General Joseph Ferguson also found that the commission overestimated payments of $16.1 million to certified women-owned businesses by 3 percent. And he alleged that the commission was not complying with its responsibility to allow him to probe all projects involving city money.
In 2009, the commission spent $243.3 million on 15 projects that included the construction of police stations, libraries, schools and field houses.
At the time, the panel was controlled by former Mayor Richard Daley. New Mayor Rahm Emanuel, whose administration did not have an immediate response to the report, led his first commission meeting Tuesday.
“We need to review it before we can comment,” said Mimi Simon, a spokeswoman for the commission.
Payments to certified minority- and women-owned businesses were overstated because the commission did not thoroughly track actual payments to specific vendors and in some cases included unqualified minority- and women-owned businesses, the report concludes.
City goals call for 25 percent of all contract payments go to minority firms and 5 percent to female firms. Emanuel recently switched oversight of those goals from the Office of Compliance to the Office of Procurement.
City Council Black Caucus Chairman Ald. Howard Brookins Jr., 21st, said he wasn't surprised to learn the minority contractor numbers at the building commission were lower than had been reported. “Minority contractors are consistently telling us the numbers are low” across city government, Brookins said.
He said he is hopeful Emanuel, as the board’s new chairman, will take the lead on rectifying the situation.
“I think he's been on target with a lot of the charges he has been championing so far,” Brookins said. “I believe he will address this, and I'm going to be there in his ear to be sure this is something at the top of his list of things to do.”
Ferguson’s report comes about a week after an earlier one that followed up on an earlier conclusion that the city’s program to enforce the goals was beset by “widespread fraud, abuse and mismanagement.”
The two reports can be found here.