The trade deadline can be a dangerous temptress.
At times, it can cause otherwise levelheaded organizations to do something crazy. Like trade away Jeff Bagwell for Larry Anderson. Or give up Grady Sizemore, Cliff Lee and Brandon Phillips for Bartolo Colon.
With a week before the July 31 deadline, though, Orioles fans can rest easy. History says any move the Orioles make at the deadline will be a good one. Or a wash at the very least.
The Orioles have never had any Bagwell-for-Anderson trades. They have made their share of regrettable moves (wherefore art thou, Curt Schilling and Steve Finley?), but they've never really given up any significant piece at the deadline, at least not without getting something of value in return.
With the Orioles considering adding a corner infield bat or starting pitcher, The Baltimore Sun has compiled a list of the O's best deals at the deadline, as well as those that had more mixed results.
The only criterion is that the deal must have been executed within a week of the trade deadline. Also note: the MLB has maintained the July 31 deadline since 1986, but before that year, the deadline was June 15.
I've broken down the trades into three categories. The Good, The Less Good and The Harold Baines, named after the player of the same name who was traded to and from Baltimore two times each. When you're in that many deals, you deserve your own category.
The Orioles never reaped the benefits of their best deadline deal. Just three years later, they traded Schilling along with Steve Finley and Pete Harnisch to Houston for Glenn Davis. Still, the 1988 deal was a gem. Schilling is a potential Hall of Famer and Anderson hit 50 home runs for the O's in 1996. Boddicker pitched two more good years and one very good year, but the second half of his career isn't close to matching Schilling's resume.
June 15, 1970: The Orioles acquired Moe Drabowsky from the Royals for Bobby Floyd.
This trade makes the list because it gave the Orioles the final piece for a World Series-winning team. The Royals received a good player in Floyd, but Drabowsky recorded three saves in the 1970 World Series to help lead Baltimore to a championship.
The Orioles addressed two needs with this deal. Even though Hunter has been disappointing, Davis' power gives the lineup some pop. And Uehara, who hasn't pitched in more than a month with a lat injury, is not missed in a bullpen that has been the team's bright spot.
Bonilla was a .300 hitter in a year and a half with the Orioles, and his addition helped the Orioles reach the ALCS in 1996.
The Less Good
This deal is more sad than anything else. None of the players involved in the trade made any major impacts after the deal, but Orioles fans will remember B.J. Surhoff crying after learning he would no longer be an Oriole.
June 15, 1976: The Orioles acquired Tippy Martinez, Rick Dempsey, Rudy May, Scott McGregor and Dave Pagan from the Yankees for Doyle Alexander, Grant Jackson, Jimmy Freeman, Elrod Hendricks and Ken Holtzman.
This trade lands in the "Less Good" category mostly for the ungodly amount of players involved. That's just messy. Plus, all but Jimmy Alexander were major leaguers.
On the positive side, the Orioles landed Martinez, who recorded a 3.46 ERA in 11 years in Baltimore. They did give up two good pieces in Alexander and Jackson, though, so this deal probably netted more negatives overall. The lesson? Never involve 8 major league players in one deal. Especially a deal with a divisional rival.
The Harold Baines
July 29, 1997: The Orioles acquired Harold Baines from the White Sox for a player to be named later (ultimately Juan Bautista).
This was the second time Baines was traded to the Orioles (he also signed or re-signed with Baltimore three times during his career). This one worked out for the O's. Baines hit .291 in 1997, including a .353 batting average in the ALCS against the Indians, though the Orioles lost that series.
July 29, 2000: The Orioles acquired Jason Lakman, Juan Figueroa, Miguel Felix and Brook Fordyce from the White Sox for Harold Baines and Charles Johnson.
By this time, the Orioles probably just dealt Baines out of habit. This deal, involving few players of significance, was the fourth time the O's had been involved in a trade including Baines and their second deadline deal involving the veteran.
So what can we learn from all of this? For one, the Orioles rarely make mistakes at the deadline, though they sometimes save those mistakes for the rest of the year.
Also, don't be surprised if Harold Baines comes out of retirement this week just so the Orioles can trade for him.