Rafael Neddermeyer, Getty Images
December 4, 2013
The Fickle Fish kept us guessing all year. Is he returning to swimming? And who is he dating now? The Olympic swimming superstar started off the year breaking up with his model/waitress girlfriend, then heading to Cabo San Lucas, Mexico, with another model/waitress for some lobster fishing (that's what the kids are calling it these days). But the sun soon set on Phelps' tropical romance, and he began practicing his swing with Golf Channel reporter Win McMurry, whom is he reportedly still dating.